TL;DR
HubPeople owner Michael O’Sullivan is asking Apple to review how App Store Guideline 4.3 applies to dating apps that share features but serve different communities. He says HubPeople has faced rejections and wants to provide examples to Apple’s policy team; Apple has not responded in the information available.
HubPeople owner Michael O’Sullivan is calling on Apple to review how its App Store Guideline 4.3 is applied to dating apps, arguing that apps with similar features can serve different communities and should not automatically be treated as spam. The issue matters to smaller dating businesses seeking to reach established audiences through dedicated apps, though Apple’s position on O’Sullivan’s request is not reported.
Get gifts for the two of you delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Guideline 4.3 allows Apple to reject apps it considers spam, including apps that offer features similar to those of existing platforms. O’Sullivan’s objection, set out in a commentary published on HubPeople, is that a feature-based comparison may overlook the people an app is designed to connect. Dating services commonly include profiles, matching and messaging, he notes, while their audiences and communities can differ.
O’Sullivan says HubPeople has encountered the issue itself, including rejections involving established dating businesses with existing customers. He says discussions with the Online Dating and Discovery Association (ODDA) have led him to understand that other industry members have faced similar problems. The number of affected developers, the reasons given in individual Apple decisions and the specific apps involved are not detailed.
He wants to engage with Apple’s App Store policy team, share examples of rejected applications and hear from other developers with similar experiences. O’Sullivan says he supports strong safety, privacy and quality standards, but questions whether Apple’s interpretation of the rule should determine which legitimate dating communities can have their own apps.
Why HubPeople Wants Apple to Revisit Dating App Rules
HubPeople owner Michael O’Sullivan wants Apple to review how Guideline 4.3 applies to dating apps serving different communities. No response or policy change from Apple is reported.
What the rule covers
Guideline 4.3 allows Apple to reject apps it considers spam, including apps with features similar to existing platforms.
- Profiles
- Matching
- Messaging
- Different communities may use similar features
- Audience can be central to a dating service’s value
Why businesses care
App review can affect whether dating companies reach users through a dedicated iPhone app.
Approval affects access
Smaller operators may struggle to distinguish apps for specific audiences from competing products.
Communities seek access
Dedicated apps can connect people in established dating communities.
What O’Sullivan wants next
He says he wants to bring examples to Apple’s App Store policy team and hear from other developers.
Discuss rejected applications with Apple’s policy team.
Collect similar experiences from other industry members.
Ask how distinct communities are considered under Guideline 4.3.
How App Review Shapes Dating Competition
Apple’s app review decisions can affect whether a dating company reaches users through a dedicated iPhone app. If two services are judged mainly by shared features, a smaller operator may have difficulty distinguishing an app built around a specific audience from a competing product, even when the services serve different groups. That could make app approval a business constraint as well as a technical review.
O’Sullivan’s argument is that the audience is central to a dating service’s value: “The people ARE the product,” he writes. The statement is his view, not a change to Apple policy or an independent finding about how the review process works. If Apple were to clarify its approach, that could affect how dating businesses plan new brands and how niche communities access services. No policy revision has been announced.
The debate also involves competing considerations. Apple’s rule is intended to address spam and similar submissions, while O’Sullivan says the same test can disadvantage legitimate services. The available account does not establish how Apple balances those concerns or whether rejected apps could qualify after changes or appeal.
Popular right now

Breville Barista Express Manual Espresso Machine with Built-In Grinder, Brushed Stainless Steel

Dyson V9 Motorbar Cordless Vacuum

Sony WH-1000XM6 Wireless Noise-Canceling Headphones, Black
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
The Rule and HubPeople’s Objection
Guideline 4.3 concerns spam and apps that Apple considers too similar to existing offerings. The dispute described by O’Sullivan is not that dating apps have wholly different mechanics; rather, he argues that shared functions such as profiles and messaging do not mean their communities are interchangeable. His requested review focuses on how Apple evaluates that distinction.
Commentator Mark Brooks, identified in the commentary as a HubPeople client, says the company is launching high-end dating app brands that Apple has rejected as too similar. Brooks argues that HubPeople’s model begins with an existing database of users, rather than an empty service, and therefore avoids what he calls the “cold start problem.” Those are Brooks’s claims about HubPeople’s approach; details about the size or composition of its user database are not provided.
O’Sullivan’s reference to conversations with ODDA offers a sign that the concern may extend beyond HubPeople, but it does not establish how widespread the problem is. No list of affected companies, rejection decisions or Apple policy documents beyond Guideline 4.3 is included in the account.
““The people ARE the product.””
— Michael O’Sullivan, HubPeople owner
Apple’s Response and Rejection Details
It is not clear whether Apple has received a formal request from O’Sullivan, whether the company will meet with him or whether it plans to reconsider its guidance. No response from Apple is reported. The particular rejection notices, their dates and Apple’s explanations are also not provided, so the individual review decisions cannot be independently assessed here.
The scale of the issue remains uncertain. O’Sullivan says ODDA discussions suggest other industry members have encountered similar problems, but no count or names are given. It is also unclear whether Apple’s decisions turned only on similarity of features or included other review concerns, and whether the affected apps pursued an appeal.
A Requested Policy Discussion
O’Sullivan says he wants to take examples of rejected applications to Apple’s App Store policy team and hear from developers who have faced comparable decisions. That outreach and any resulting discussion are prospective; no meeting date, Apple commitment or timetable for a policy review is reported.
Further detail from Apple, HubPeople or other developers could clarify how Guideline 4.3 is being applied and whether the disputed decisions involve similar circumstances. For now, the confirmed development is a call for review, not a change to the rule or a finding that Apple has rejected apps solely because they serve niche dating communities.
Source: rss
Key Questions
What is HubPeople asking Apple to do?
HubPeople owner Michael O’Sullivan wants Apple to review how Guideline 4.3 is applied to dating apps that share common features but serve different communities. He also wants to discuss rejected applications with Apple’s policy team.
What does App Store Guideline 4.3 cover?
The guideline allows Apple to reject apps it considers spam, including apps that offer features similar to existing platforms. The account does not provide the full text of the guideline or Apple’s assessment of specific HubPeople apps.
What does HubPeople say is wrong with the current approach?
O’Sullivan argues that comparing functions such as profiles, matching and messaging can miss the communities a dating app serves. He says HubPeople has faced rejections involving established businesses with customers.
Has Apple agreed to change its rules?
No policy change or Apple response is reported. O’Sullivan says he wants to engage with Apple’s App Store policy team, but a meeting or review has not been confirmed.
Source: globaldatinginsights.com
