If you’re searching for a “girlfriend for sale” novelty gift, these two water-activated figures offer different kinds of gag appeal. I’d choose the Rhode Island Novelty 12-count display for party favors and group giveaways, while the Forum Novelties single figure is the stronger pick for someone who wants a reusable, slowly expanding desk gag. The main tradeoff is quantity versus individual growth: one box supplies a dozen small figures, while the single item can grow up to six times its original size but may take as long as 72 hours to reach full size.
Get gifts for the two of you delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Neither is a conventional toy with complex play features; the appeal is the simple water-activated transformation. I’ve ranked them by how well each fits its likely use, how clearly the listed details support that use, and what a buyer gives up in return. That distinction matters: a bulk pack makes sharing easy, but the single figure offers a more dramatic stated expansion and repeat-growing feature.
Key Takeaways
- Choose the Rhode Island Novelty set when you need 12 individually packaged gag favors or giveaways.
- Choose the Forum Novelties figure for a single recipient who may enjoy repeating the water-growth gag.
- Forum states growth of up to six times the original size, but reaching full size can take up to 72 hours.
- The Rhode Island Novelty figures start at 2.7 inches and grow to nearly double their original size.
- Both options are manually operated; neither requires batteries, and neither is suited to anyone expecting fast results.
| Grow A Girlfriend Water-Activated Novelty Toy, 12-Count Display |  | Best Overall for Party Favors | Brand: Rhode Island Novelty | Quantity: 12 figures | Starting size: 2.7 inches | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Forum Novelties Grow a Girlfriend Gag Novelty |  | Best for Repeat-Growing Gag Appeal | Brand: Forum Novelties | Model: 75929 | Package quantity: 1 | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| girlfriend for sale | Brand | Material | Operation | Quantity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Grow A Girlfriend Water-Activa | Rhode Island Novelty | Polymer | Manual; water-activated | 12 figures |
| Forum Novelties Grow a Girlfri | Forum Novelties | Plastic | Manual; no batteries required | — |
More Details on Our Top Picks
Grow A Girlfriend Water-Activated Novelty Toy, 12-Count Display
I rank the Rhode Island Novelty 12-count display first because its strongest advantage is practical: one purchase supplies a dozen separately packaged figures. That makes it a better fit than the Forum single for party favors, small giveaways, or a group gag where each person should get one. The retail-ready display box also suits handing the novelties out without repacking them individually.
Each figure starts at 2.7 inches and grows to nearly double its original size in water. That promises a visible, uncomplicated transformation, but it is a more modest stated expansion than Forum’s claim of up to six times the original size. Buyers who care most about the biggest growth effect may prefer the Forum figure; buyers who need several small gifts will get more from this set.
The tradeoff is that the product’s value is tied to quantity rather than a more elaborate experience. The listed details don’t give a growth timeline or say whether these figures can be grown repeatedly, so I wouldn’t choose this pack over Forum on repeat use or speed. Its small starting size may also make each figure feel more like a token favor than a substantial standalone gift. Still, for a gag favor that can be shared with a group, this is the clearest all-around match in the pair.
Pros:- Includes 12 individually blister-packed figures
- Display box is ready for presenting or distributing
- Water activation creates a simple visual gag
- Suitable for party favors and group giveaways
Cons:- Each figure starts at just 2.7 inches
- Listed expansion is nearly double, less than Forum’s up-to-six-times claim
- The supplied details do not state a growth timeline or repeat-use capability
Best for: Hosts, organizers, and gift buyers who need multiple individually packaged gag novelties for parties, favors, or giveaways.
Not ideal for: Someone seeking one keepsake-style figure, the largest stated expansion, or confirmed repeat-growing instructions.
- Brand:Rhode Island Novelty
- Quantity:12 figures
- Starting size:2.7 inches
- Expansion:Grows to nearly double its original size in water
- Material:Polymer
- Color:Pink
- Operation:Manual; water-activated
- Usage:Indoor
- Model number:JK-GRGIR/RI
Our verdict“I recommend this 12-pack for group occasions where individually packaged favors matter more than maximum expansion or documented repeat use.”
Forum Novelties Grow a Girlfriend Gag Novelty
The Forum Novelties Grow a Girlfriend is the better choice when one recipient matters more than handing out a batch. Its key differentiator is the stated expansion of up to six times its original size, which is more dramatic on paper than the Rhode Island Novelty figures’ near-doubling. Forum also says the figure can be grown repeatedly, giving the gag a second angle beyond a one-time reveal.
That repeat-use detail comes with a patience requirement. Growth begins after about two hours, and reaching full size can take up to 72 hours. Compared with the 12-pack, this is not the pick for a party moment where everyone expects an immediate payoff. It suits a recipient who enjoys checking in on a slow transformation and doesn’t mind waiting for it.
Once removed from water, the figure gradually shrinks, so the expanded state is not described as permanent. The package quantity is one, unlike the Rhode Island Novelty set, and the supplied information does not include a display box or a range of figures for sharing. I’d favor Forum for a single, repeatable desk gag; I’d skip it for a crowd, a time-sensitive gift, or anyone who expects the figure to stay expanded after it leaves the water.
Pros:- Stated expansion is up to six times the original size
- Can be grown repeatedly according to the product description
- Manual operation requires no batteries
- A single-figure format suits an individual gag gift
Cons:- May take up to 72 hours to reach full size
- Gradually shrinks when removed from water
- One figure provides less for group occasions than the 12-count set
Best for: A gag-gift recipient who wants one figure that can be grown repeatedly and is happy to wait for a gradual transformation.
Not ideal for: Party hosts who need several favors, buyers who want a quick reveal, or anyone expecting the expanded size to remain after removal from water.
- Brand:Forum Novelties
- Model:75929
- Package quantity:1
- Material:Plastic
- Growth:Up to six times original size
- Time to begin growing:About 2 hours
- Time to reach full size:Up to 72 hours
- Operation:Manual; no batteries required
- Item dimensions:2 x 0.75 x 0.5 inches
Our verdict“I’d pick Forum for a patient recipient who values repeated growth and a larger stated transformation over quantity and speed.”
How We Picked
I ranked these products around the specific intent behind “girlfriend for sale”: finding a playful, water-activated gag novelty rather than a serious toy or relationship product. I compared the supplied details for quantity, stated expansion, timing, repeat use, and likely occasion. Those factors reveal the biggest practical divide: the Rhode Island Novelty product is packaged for distributing to a group, while the Forum Novelties item is presented as one reusable figure for a slower, more drawn-out gag.
I also weighed claims only as they are described in the product information. The Rhode Island Novelty listing says its figures grow to nearly double their starting size; Forum gives a larger claim of up to six times the original size, alongside a growth timeline of about two hours to begin and up to 72 hours for full size. I treat those as different product claims, not as a guarantee that every figure will reach an exact result. The descriptions do not specify details such as water temperature, care instructions, or long-term durability, so I don’t use those points to separate the picks.
My order gives the bulk set the lead because it has a clear advantage for parties and giveaways, where having individually packed pieces is the point. Forum ranks second overall but takes the lead for repeat use and a more pronounced stated expansion. Both have a clear drawback: the first starts small and expands less, while the second requires patience and gradually shrinks after it leaves the water.
| girlfriend for sale | Brand | Material | Operation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grow A Girlfriend Water-Activa | Rhode Island Novelty | Polymer | Manual; water-activated |
| Forum Novelties Grow a Girlfri | Forum Novelties | Plastic | Manual; no batteries required |
Factors to Consider When Choosing Girlfriend For Sale
I’d make this choice by starting with the occasion, then checking how much patience and repeat use the recipient is likely to enjoy. The products share a water-activated novelty concept, but they solve different buying problems.Choose by quantity and occasion
For a party, classroom-style giveaway, or group gag, the 12-count Rhode Island Novelty display is the straightforward choice. Individually blister-packed figures are easier to distribute than a single shared novelty, and the display box gives the set a presentation advantage. Forum’s one-item package makes more sense as a personal gag gift than as a supply for a group.
If you only need one figure, quantity should not decide the purchase for you. Compare the recipient’s interest in repeat use and the stated growth instead. Forum offers a single-figure experience with repeat-growing potential, while the 12-pack prioritizes having extras ready for multiple people.
Compare the growth claims carefully
The listed expansion figures are not the same: Rhode Island Novelty says nearly double the starting size, while Forum says up to six times the original size. If a more pronounced transformation is your main goal, Forum has the stronger stated claim. If you’d rather buy for quantity and share the gag, the smaller expansion claim may be an acceptable tradeoff.
These are product descriptions, not a promise that every figure will reach an exact size under every set of conditions. I would not treat the larger claim alone as proof that Forum is the better purchase for everyone; its long growth period and single-piece package change the practical fit.
Decide how much waiting is acceptable
Forum gives the clearer timeline: growth may start after about two hours, with full size taking up to 72 hours. That schedule can suit a slow-burn gag, but it is a poor match for a last-minute reveal. The Rhode Island Novelty description does not provide timing, so I would avoid assuming it grows faster simply because no long wait is listed.
If timing matters, check the product’s current instructions before buying or gifting. Neither supplied description establishes a fast, exact result, and a water-activated novelty is better treated as a gradual activity than as an instant toy.
Think about repeat use and what happens out of water
Forum is the only option here whose description explicitly says the figure can be grown repeatedly. That makes it the better fit for someone who may enjoy watching the process more than once. Its drawback is also explicit: it gradually shrinks when removed from the water, so the expanded form should not be treated as permanent.
The Rhode Island Novelty listing does not specify repeat-growing behavior. If that feature is a deciding factor, Forum has the clearer case; if your goal is to hand out novelty favors, the 12-pack’s known quantity matters more than an unlisted reuse claim.
Check size and gift expectations
Rhode Island Novelty lists a 2.7-inch starting size, while Forum lists item dimensions of 2 x 0.75 x 0.5 inches. Those figures describe the products before growth, not the full expanded result. Both begin as small novelty items, so neither should be bought as a substantial figure or a detailed play toy.
I’d match the gift to someone who enjoys simple gag items and the waiting or water-based activity. For a recipient who prefers an immediate, durable display piece, these products may not fit: Forum can shrink out of water, and the supplied Rhode Island Novelty details do not describe a lasting expanded state.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which “girlfriend for sale” novelty is better for a party?
I’d choose the Rhode Island Novelty 12-count display for a party or group giveaway. It includes a dozen individually packaged figures, while Forum Novelties supplies one. The tradeoff is that the set’s listed growth is nearly double, rather than Forum’s claim of up to six times its original size.
Which product has the larger stated expansion?
Forum Novelties has the larger listed claim: up to six times its original size. Rhode Island Novelty says its figures grow to nearly double their starting size. These are descriptions of the products’ stated growth, not a guarantee of an exact result for every figure.
How long does the Forum Novelties figure take to grow?
Forum says the figure begins expanding after about two hours and can take up to 72 hours to reach full size. I’d choose it for a gradual gag rather than a quick reveal. The Rhode Island Novelty listing does not provide a comparable timeline.
Can the Forum Novelties figure be used more than once?
Yes. The product description says the Forum figure can be grown repeatedly. It also says the item gradually shrinks when removed from water, so buyers should not expect it to stay expanded permanently. The Rhode Island Novelty description does not specify whether its figures can be grown again.
Do either of these novelty figures need batteries?
No. Both are described as manual, water-activated novelties, and the Forum listing specifically says it requires no batteries. The main practical requirement is water and patience, particularly for Forum, whose full growth may take up to 72 hours.
Conclusion
My recommendation depends on who will receive the gag. For party hosts and buyers who need several favors, I’d choose the Rhode Island Novelty 12-count set: it is packaged for sharing, though each figure starts small and its listed growth is more modest. For one patient recipient who enjoys repeatable novelty, I’d choose Forum Novelties for its up-to-six-times growth claim and stated reuse, accepting the long wait and shrinking after removal from water.
If you want a fast, permanent display item, neither listing makes that promise. For the two uses these products do support—sharing a simple gag or watching one figure grow over time—the right pick is the one that matches your group size and the recipient’s patience.
